Home

PLANNING FOR PROSPERITY:

PROCEEDINGS FOR THE HANCOCK COUNTY

REGIONAL GROWTH SYMPOSIUM

January 27, 2001

 

Funding for this project was provided by the Maine Community Foundation, the Maine Department of Transportation, the Coastal Program of the Maine State Planning Office, the Maine Rural Development Council and the Hancock County Planning Commission. Opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of the funding agencies.

Introduction

This is a summary of the proceedings from the January 27, 2001 Symposium "Planning for Prosperity" held at the Holiday Inn in Ellsworth, Maine. Due the large number of participants (105 people attended) and the many ideas expressed, it was not possible to record every idea expressed. Also, since each break out session was reported differently, the format varies. Rather, this summary tries to capture the spirit of the day. Those interested in a copy of the more detailed proceedings are urged to contact the Hancock County Planning Commission.

OPENING SESSION

Personal Account of Hancock County History - Dennis Damon, County Commissioner

Commissioner Damon spoke of his experiences growing up in the village of Northeast Harbor at a time when 600 people lived there year-round, some summer people and no tourists.. He stressed that it is not so important where you were born, but that you live here now. He remembers all the houses in town and everyone’s names. A shopping trip to Ellsworth was a big deal, perhaps once a year. For advice, he suggested that Charles Darwin meant by survival of the fittest, survival of the most adaptable. He also reminded us that Wayne Gretsky succeeded by skating to where the puck was going to be.

Recent Trends and Forecasts for Hancock County - Jim Fisher, HCPC Planner

Detailed Presentation with Graphics

MORNING BREAK OUT SESSIONS

  1. Land Use SESSION

Ted Koffman, College of the Atlantic

Issues

  • Comprehensive Local/Regional Land Use Planning:
  • Year Round Jobs:
  • Wilderness/Wildlife Habitat Protection:
  • Opportunities

    1. Business and Economic Development Session

    David Cole, Eastern Maine Development Corporation

    Issues

      There is clear agreement among session participants that the following are priority issues confronting the future Hancock County. First and foremost is the human resource issue of young people leaving the area. How to reverse this out-migration trend is key. Cost of doing business in the area is just as critical, if not more so. "Cost" relates to myriad of issues including worker compensation, tax and regulations. The "danger of unplanned and unmanaged growth" and how that may affect business retention and economic development in the region also percolated to the top of the priority list. "Green space," "clean environment," "quality of life," "recreational facilities" are all inter-connected aspects of the underlying growth management issue.

    Opportunities

    Hancock County needs to target and capitalize on its many assets strategically. There are already strong institutions in the region: banking, education (K-12 systems as well as UMAINE, Eastern Maine Technical College and College of the Atlantic), research and development (Jackson Laboratory and MDI Biological Laboratory), and business (tourism and the boat yards).

    There is debate among the economic development field whether to nurture and grow existing businesses (and help sprout new ones), or lure in firms from elsewhere. For the session participants, the response is to do both. Underlying this response is the realization that many of the conditions that make a community good for business are good for all businesses - whether new or existing, locally grown or externally recruited. These conditions include "quality of life," equitable benefits, living wage and a "healthy workforce."

    For this response to work on both fronts, there must be coordinated targeting of public and private sector resources - technical assistance, financing, work force training, infrastructure development, transportation and transit assistance, etc. In this context also, entrepreneurship needs to be considered as a strategy for rural development. Small towns and villages often lack the capacity to mount a full-scale effort. Economic development in the region, therefore, must entail "community building." That is, the civic capacity - local leadership, vision, knowledge of place and its assets, institutions, citizen engagement, and the like - must be enhanced.

    3. Transportation SESSION

    Access Management - Kathy Fuller and Mike Hoover, MDOT

    Population growth is slow but vehicle-miles traveled are growing at a much faster rate. This means that the traffic growth is not so much because there are more people but because the people in Hancock County are driving more (longer and more frequent trips) to get to work, to conduct business or to recreate. This trend has a direct correlation with the "spreading out" pattern of development the entire state is experiencing and translates into more dollars spent on vehicle maintenance and fuel as well as increases in highway wear and tear. The end result is less disposable income and more highway improvement need. Congestion causes delays and costs Hancock County $22 million annually will increase to $31 million in the future. These costs include fuel, time, vehicle wear, delays for freight, etc.

    MDOT wants to protect arterials in particular; the most expensive highways to build or replace. They are a relatively small percentage of the roadways in the state, but very prone to congestion because they are designed to carry and move the most traffic. The important thing is to keep the traffic moving and to plan access points in such a way as to balance the needs of those who need to access adjacent land with the needs of those who depend on through travel to make a living. With Ellsworth as the hub, access management policies will be very important to consider.

    Three reasons for promoting access management.

    Passenger Transportation - David Nelson, MDOT

    MDOT launching Calais Branch Rail corridor study, exploring light rail opportunities and

    considering building a rail line extension from Ellsworth to Trenton

    - Evaluating financing needs (political decision)

    - Evaluating other options for moving people - Rail, bus, bus-way

    - MDOT is building infrastructure to support Ferry service in this region.

    Issues

    1. Lack of long term and regional thinking, action on transportation issues. At times this has fostered a cycle that increases the problems: traffic increases, so roads are improved or new roads constructed, so that we can increase traffic and so on.
    2. There is severe (for rural Maine) congestion and traffic delay due to seasonal tourism and year-round commuter patterns.
    3. We face health problems due to poor air quality, a significant portion of which stems from our reliance on automobiles. Cardio-vascular health problems stem from our dependence on the automobile and from our concerns about safety we hesitate to walk or ride bicycles.
    4. We have an aging infrastructure supporting our reliance on automobiles
    5. When traffic congestion increases on major state roads in Hancock County, people switch to local roads which were not constructed to handle the number, speed and size of vehicles making these local roads unsafe for the purposes for which they were intended.
    6. There are clear funding constraints for many of the improvements and innovations that will be necessary to ease our transportation problems.
    7. Individuals who do not have cars, have difficulty participating in the life of the community, in getting to jobs, in getting health care.

    Opportunities

    1. We can see that all appropriate parties coordinate their efforts in transportation planning and implementing the plans: citizens, local towns, county government and agencies.
    2. We can develop the full array of public transit options and services: busses, ferries, trains and light-rail, air service, van-pooling, bikeways and pedestrian ways, at the same time we improve the safety of our existing roads, through engineering and managing access to state owned roads.
    3. We can create a by-pass, which will help assure that those people who live in Ellsworth as well as those needing to shop and get services, attend events in Ellsworth can do so with safety and convenience, while those who need to get around Ellsworth can do so.

    Priorities

    1. Immediate concerns - congestion in the Ellsworth Corridor

    2. Long range opportunities - better regional coordination in transportation planning

    3. Health issues of environmental quality and exercise emerges as a third issue

     

    Luncheon Speaker: Economic Profile of Hancock County

    Charles Colgan, University of Southern Maine

    Hancock County has one of the fastest growing economies in the state in percentage terms

    The economy is growing more diversified, unemployment has been declining since 1992, setting historic lows. Hancock County has foundations on which to build:

    Natural Resources (ocean, coast, scenery)

    Key employers

    -IP - modern, profitable mill, large well maintained land-base, but subject to dramatic changes, over-capacity in paper making, highly competitive

    -Jackson Labs - dramatic success story, great potential, but no clear reason for being in Bar Harbor.

    -Hinckley - another world leader, but subject to stock market cycles, will have difficult times in a downturn

    "Dying distance" - location is less of an issue, Internet, etc. permit virtual offices

    Elements of strategy:

    - Employment market is not growing, so recruiting won't be easy.

    - Need to do more training through schools for the long term, on the job training,

    - Sprawl is when you do things wrong, costs are high, aesthetics low, land use inefficient

    - Need to have growth for prosperity, but this does not mean sprawl.

    - Land and Water - need to manage water areas too. Hancock County needs to develop a sense of the ocean as a place that needs to be managed.

    Learning / 'Learning regions' - learning itself is valued

    Envisioning - Planning - process/not product

    Business Existing, New, Relocated

    Government-The right R - 'Regional' - The process requires lots of meetings

    Non Profits

    - Mortar (not bricks) created to do things that government and business do not do (well)

    - Maine is rich in donations of time rather than money

    Baker Island was not a romantic place. The one family had to deal with the reality of life.

    Making a place unattractive is not a viable option.

    Planning and cooperation are not natural acts. They are a lot of work

    Retiring baby boomers will create a boom in tourism

    Density is not the end of the world. To preserve what is rural you need to develop urban.

    Islands prosper by connecting, not by insularity.

     

    VALUES, VISION AND ACTION (Afternoon Session)

    The symposium was divided into four working groups. Each group was charged with identifying what they valued, their vision for the future and action steps for reaching the desired future. The following is a consolidated list of findings from these four groups.

    Values

    Community

    • Collaboration and consensus in decision making.
    • Communities that nurture variety in employment, education and housing; cooperative, imaginative planning.
    • Functioning community that encourages and utilizes ongoing citizen input; has working infrastructure; provides decent opportunities for work, housing and recreation.
    • Heritage/traditions/places/buildings
    • Rural community character; the quality of life and a vision for growth at all levels.
    • The friendliness of the citizens of Ellsworth and their willingness to work together.

    Economy

    • Flourishing business and non-profit community
    • Quality of education opportunities.
    • Meaningful and rewarding jobs.
    • Services are affordable and accessible

    Land Use and Environment

    • Buildings are high quality with good design, including public realm/landscape
    • Community that integrates land use so that one can live, work and play in the same place which can be accessed without a vehicle.
    • Green space within a city center and sidewalks on which to get there.
    • Preservation of historic and archaeological sites of Hancock County.
    • Preservation of our lakes, ocean and wildlife habitat.
    • Rural nature of my community
    • Scenic and environmental quality.
    • Uniqueness of "place"-want to retain distinction and not allow rural area to be indistinct from other places in the nation (or urban become indistinguishable from rural).

    Transportation

    • Ease of movement; business - less with Maine taxes and regulation;
    • No congestion on the roads
    • Population is mostly residing close/in town, density is designed for livability

    Vision

    Community

    • Healthy Community - clean and safe environment,
    • Adequate exercise is a part of everyday existence.
    • Vital, interactive community - lot of community activities
    • Active and plentiful arts-cultural life as community resources
    • Responsive, forward thinking leaders, vision and engaged public
    • Bus and rail public transportation very accessible, user-friendly alternative to car.

    Natural Resources and Economy

    • Open space is preserved for public use - including access to water and forests
    • Traditional resources based activities are sustained
    • Hancock County has expanded opportunities for lifelong education
    • Economy further diversifies, with year-round and counter cyclical jobs
    • Active, flourishing family farms
    • Small manufactures and businesses and value to natural resource materials

    Next Steps

    Study

    • Build GIS capabilities to help communities in order to assist planning processes.
    • Identify the watersheds and vulnerable habitats in the Ellsworth area
    • Corridor study on traffic and transportation

    Plan

    • Encourage my town government to work cooperatively with one region in developing a county-wide economic plan.
    • Urge my town government to work on a regional plan to preserve the ecology and natural beauty of Hancock County.
    • Get involved with resilient comprehensive plan.
    • Cooperate with others and develop a 20 year plan for county.
    • Encourage towns to engage in comprehensive planning

    Educate

    • Foster discussion of quality of the built environment.
    • Promote enlightened housing options.
    • Planning education at High School level

    Organize

    • Stay involved in local government and speak up.
    • Align business interest with personal/community vision of state and counties vision.
    • Participate in conservation organization.
    • Become a leader for organizations in education, customer services and community cooperation.
    • Create an agenda for change, create future forum to meet on a regular basis
    • Look at big picture- $ incentives for regional approach

    Implement

    • Endeavor to work to have no pollution from businesses, residential areas, industries or recreational activities/facilities through ordinances and public education.
    • Less cars on Main Street and more walking after a bypass is developed around downtown.
    • Build paved shoulders, bike trails and sidewalks
    • Create industrial and business parks with first class infrastructure.
    • Develop infrastructure to support comfortable density and protect rural land from sprawl